The Unique Nystagmus of the Zuma Maneuver for Apogeotropic Horizontal Canal BPPV: A Deep Dive

Photo by frank mckenna on Unsplash

As a physical therapist specializing in vestibular and balance disorders, I'm always fascinated by the intricate dance between head position, inner ear mechanics, and the resulting eye movements we observe in patients with Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo (BPPV). While maneuvers like the Epley and the Semont are well-known for treating posterior canal BPPV, the horizontal canal presents unique challenges and requires specific approaches. One such approach is the Zuma maneuver.

The Zuma maneuver is a valuable tool for addressing horizontal canal BPPV. While practical, one particularly intriguing aspect of this maneuver is the distinct nystagmus pattern that emerges, especially when treating the apogeotropic variant. Understanding this pattern isn't just academic; it's crucial for confirming the diagnosis, monitoring the movement of debris, and ensuring the maneuver is performed correctly.

Let's zoom in on the Zuma maneuver for a patient with right horizontal canal apogeotropic BPPV (canalithiasis), and explore the nystagmus you should expect to see at each step. Remember, with apogeotropic horizontal canal BPPV, the initial nystagmus in the supine roll test beats away from the earth (apogeotropic). This indicates the otoconia are free-floating in the anterior arm of the horizontal canal.

Position 1 & 2: Sitting to Sidelying on the Affected Side (Right)

You begin by quickly moving the patient from sitting to lying on their affected side – in this case, the right side. As the debris, now free-floating, moves away from the ampulla in the anterior arm of the horizontal canal (ampullofugal movement in this orientation), you will observe a left-beating nystagmus. This is consistent with Ewald's second law, which states that ampullofugal flow in the horizontal canal causes an inhibitory response due to the orientation of the hair cells. According to Tate's rule, the nystagmus always beats towards the more nerve-active side. In this inhibitory scenario on the right, the left horizontal canal is relatively more active, driving a left-beating nystagmus. You hold this position, waiting for the nystagmus to fatigue, typically for one to three minutes, to allow the debris to settle.

Position 3: Nose Up (Supine with Cervical Flexion 30 degrees)

After the nystagmus in Position 1 & 2 has fatigued, you briskly turn the patient to a nose-up position (supine with approximately 30 degrees of cervical flexion). This is where a classic and often unexpected pattern continues. As the debris continues its journey through the horizontal canal, moving towards the intermediate segment, it creates an inhibitory stimulus in the right horizontal canal. Consequently, you should continue to see a left-beating nystagmus. This persistent left beat in the nose-up position indicates that the debris is moving as expected and has not fallen back. Observing the orthotropic nystagmus is vital here. Once this nystagmus also fatigues, it signals that the debris has successfully navigated around the intermediate segment and is beginning to enter the posterior arm of the horizontal canal.

Position 4: Sidelying on the Unaffected Side (Left)

The next step is to turn the patient over to their left side briskly. Now, the right ear, the affected ear, is the upward ear. However, the crucial point is the continued ampullofugal movement of the debris within the horizontal canal relative to the cupula in this position. This ongoing inhibitory stimulus in the right horizontal canal will again produce a left-beating nystagmus, now Geotropic Nystagmus. So, you start with a left beat in the initial sidelying position, continue to see a left beat with the Nose up, and observe another left beat when the affected ear is up. This consistent leftward nystagmus throughout the key steps for a right apogeotropic canalithiasis is a hallmark of a successful Zuma maneuver in progress. You hold this position, allowing the debris to settle further towards the utricle.

Concluding Position 5: Head Hanging (45° Nose Down)

While some descriptions of the Zuma maneuver may vary slightly, it makes perfect physiological sense to finish the maneuver by bringing the patient to a head-hanging position, similar to the end of a Gufoni maneuver. This 45-degree nose-down position uses gravity to encourage any remaining particles to move into the utricle. Although the nystagmus in this final position might be minimal or absent if the debris has cleared, it is the logical conclusion to facilitate complete particle repositioning. You maintain this position for one to two minutes before slowly bringing the patient to a sitting position.

Upon returning to sitting, the same phenomenon of brief, transient nystagmus can occur as the inner ear fluids settle, but everything should be reversed compared to the initial provocative testing.

Understanding the "Why"

The consistent left-beating nystagmus throughout the main steps of the Zuma maneuver for right horizontal canal apogeotropic BPPV is a beautiful demonstration of vestibular principles in action. It underscores the importance of:

• Ewald's 1st & 2nd Laws: The first law states that each canal has a distinctive eye movement, with the HSC, it is right or left beating. The second law states that ampullopetal flow of fluid or debris in the hSC is excitatory; therefore, ampullofugal flow is inhibitory.

• Tate's Rule: The nystagmus beats towards the relatively more nerve-active side.

Visualizing the path of the otoconia as they are guided through the canal by the sequence of head positions is a key aspect of the Zuma maneuver. This understanding allows us to predict and monitor the movement of the debris, giving us a sense of control and skill in our treatment approach. By carefully observing the nystagmus at each step, clinicians can confirm they are on the right track and that the debris is moving towards the utricle. This specific nystagmus pattern, unique to the Zuma maneuver, is a powerful diagnostic and treatment monitoring tool, providing reassurance and confidence in our approach.

This same sequence of events, with the corresponding nystagmus patterns reversed (right-beating), would be expected when performing the Zuma maneuver for left horizontal canal apogeotropic BPPV.

Understanding these detailed responses allows us to move beyond just performing a maneuver and truly appreciate the underlying mechanics of how we are helping our patients achieve — and maintain — balance. This deeper understanding enhances our clinical skills and fosters a greater appreciation for the complexity and precision of vestibular therapy. It underscores the importance of knowing how to perform a maneuver and understanding why and how it works.