As vestibular professionals, we're constantly refining our approach to gaze stabilization, a cornerstone of vestibular rehabilitation. We teach our patients the Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex (VOR) x1 and x2 exercises, emphasizing head and eye movements to keep a target in focus. But what if a seemingly simple variable like 'size' – both the visual target and the visual field – holds more power than we often acknowledge when optimizing VOR training? Today, I want to delve into insights inspired by the work of Dr. Fernando Vanderlinde dos Santos, a brilliant mind spanning clinical practice, academic research, and technological innovation in the world of balance and movement.
Who is Dr. Fernando Vanderlinde dos Santos?
Dr. dos Santos, a physical therapist, is a leading figure in our understanding and approach to balance disorders. His journey is a testament to the interdisciplinary nature of our field:
Clinical Roots: He began in private practice in Brazil, even pioneering his software, which integrated technologies like the Wii Balance for rehabilitation. This early experience highlights his commitment to practical, accessible solutions for patients.
Academic Depth: He pursued a PhD in Biomechanics and Movement Science at the University of Delaware, where his research honed in on multisensory weighting and fusion and the effects of repetitive head impacts. This deep dive into how the brain integrates visual, vestibular, and somatosensory inputs for balance and gaze stability is directly relevant to optimizing VOR function.
Technological Innovation: Dr. dos Santos is a Senior Applied Biomechanist at Bertec Corporation. Here, he's at the forefront of developing advanced products for healthcare, research, and training, emphasizing biomechanics and multisensory fusion. His work on force measurement platforms and head-mounted display systems, as evidenced by multiple patents where he is listed as an inventor, underscores his ability to translate complex research into tangible tools for clinicians.
Bridging Research and Practice: His earlier role as a professor at Gamesaude, teaching continued education for physical therapists using digital games and virtual reality, further solidifies his dedication to accessible and engaging rehabilitation strategies.
VOR Training: Why 'Size Matters'
In the context of VOR training, the phrase 'Size Matters' isn't just a catchy title; it refers to critical parameters of the visual target that can significantly influence VOR gain and treatment outcomes. Let’s review some key concepts to understand in VOR management.
Target Distance (Proximity): The Primary 'Size' Factor
The Principle: Research consistently shows that VOR gain, which is the ratio of the eye movement to the head movement, increases significantly as the viewing target distance decreases (i.e., when targets are closer to the eyes). This means performing VOR exercises with a near target (e.g., holding a finger close to the face) elicits a stronger VOR response than focusing on a distant target.
Why it Matters: The brain's control of gaze stability is more demanding for near targets. When a target is close, even small head movements can cause a large displacement of the image on the retina (retinal slip). The VOR needs to be highly accurate and responsive to minimize this slip and keep the image clear. Training with near targets forces the VOR to work harder and adapt to higher gains, which is crucial for patients with vestibular hypofunction who often struggle with gaze stability during everyday tasks like reading or walking while looking at close objects.
Clinical Application: This reinforces the importance of incorporating exercises where patients focus on close targets (e.g., a thumb, a card with text) held at arm's length or nearer, in addition to more distant targets like a distant wall or a tree. Varying target distance is a simple yet powerful way to grade the difficulty and effectiveness of VOR training. This fundamental principle ensures that VOR exercises effectively challenge the brain to restore optimal gaze stability in functional contexts. Here's a guide to target distances for VOR training:
Physical Target Size: A Nuanced 'Size' Consideration
The Nuance: While target distance is paramount, the actual physical size of the visual target (e.g., a large letter 'E' versus a small dot) can also play a role, albeit a more nuanced one.
Research Findings: Some studies suggest that in healthy individuals, the physical size of the target itself may not significantly affect VOR outcomes. However, some research indicates that individuals with vestibular loss may generate higher VOR gain when focusing on larger targets.
Why it Matters (for Vestibular Patients): A larger target provides a more robust visual stimulus and potentially more visual cues for the impaired vestibular system to latch onto. This might make the task easier initially, allowing the patient to achieve some level of gaze stabilization before progressing to smaller, more challenging targets that require finer VOR control.
Clinical Application: For patients with profound vestibular deficits, starting with larger visual targets might facilitate initial success and confidence, gradually progressing to smaller targets as VOR adaptation improves. This allows for a more graded and patient-specific approach to VOR habituation and adaptation exercises. This graded approach will enable us to meet the patients where they are, building success and confidence before demanding finer VOR control.
Optimizing Head Speeds: Slow to Fast
As the patient progresses and VOR gain improves, we gradually increase the head speed. Aim to challenge the patient with 'faster head speeds,' as these speeds better simulate real-world head movements during activities like walking or turning quickly. Tools like accelerometers or smartphone apps, which can measure head movement and provide feedback on the speed and frequency of head oscillations, can help patients monitor and gradually increase their head oscillation frequency, providing objective feedback.
Here's a general guideline for head speeds during VOR training:
The Synergy of Expertise and 'Size Matters'
Dr. dos Santos's background perfectly aligns with and amplifies the importance of 'Size Matters' in VOR training:
Multisensory Weighting: His PhD work in multisensory weighting is directly applicable. Practical VOR training relies on the brain's ability to reweight sensory inputs (vestibular, visual, somatosensory). When a target's size or distance changes, the visual input's reliability and saliency shift, requiring the brain to adjust its reliance on different sensory cues to maintain gaze stability.
Immersive Environments & Technology: His work with Bertec and immersive labs and his historical use of Wii Balance emphasize controlled and measurable environments for rehabilitation. This technological expertise allows for precise manipulation of visual target parameters – distance, size, and context – enabling clinicians to optimize VOR training based on these 'size matters' principles. Imagine using VR to simulate various target distances and sizes, providing data-driven feedback on VOR performance.
From Research to Product: Dr. dos Santos's journey from academic research to product development at Bertec exemplifies translating scientific understanding into practical tools. The insights about 'size matters' can directly inform the design of future balance and vestibular rehabilitation systems, ensuring they incorporate optimal visual stimuli for therapeutic benefit.
Conclusion
As Brian K. Werner, PT, MPT, and National Director of Vestibular Education & Training at FYZICAL, I emphasize that understanding the intricacies of VOR training is paramount. The concept of 'Size Matters,' particularly regarding target distance and physical target size for specific patient populations, offers a powerful lens to refine our clinical practice.
By integrating Dr. Fernando Vanderlinde dos Santos's insights from multisensory research and technological innovation, we can move beyond simply telling patients to 'keep their eyes on the target.' Instead, we can strategically manipulate the visual environment to maximize VOR adaptation, leading to more effective gaze stabilization, reduced dizziness, and a better quality of life for our patients.
Share this post